Saturday, 5 July 2025

The greatest American band of all time # scientific # objectivity (by a 'Brit')

Let us establish some ground rules

We're talking bands here
solo artists with renowned backing groups
e.g. Crazy Horse / the E Street Band are clearly not bands
thus disqualified from this discussion good day

Any audience member who nominates
or leads the cheers for 70s/80s
rock stroke glam stroke hair rock bands such as
Kiss Aerosmith Van Halen Bon Jovi, Guns n Roses
- I could go on please don't- shall be found in
contempt of court and their protes-
ations shall not be admitted good day

Niche will not cut it however
sympathetic the judge may be
so sorry Pavement Pixies Fugazi et cet
we're looking for mainstream success + cultural import
the combo of 'cutting through'

So let us acknowledge
that Talking Heads and Blondie
are good calls ~and move on~

And what about the Dead
what to do with the Dead *sighs*
the court sympathizes, but
please respect the science, viz.

We need a catalogue
of well known tunes some say hits, popular
and legacy but crucially non-divisive
which sees off contenders such as
the Doors (loved by many, yet hated by many),
Steely Dan (see previous), Eagles (you get the picture)
murder your darlings //
personal favourites are irrelevant
we must respect the scientific method

Quick reminder: the Bee Gees are not American
and any votes for them will be vigorously prosecuted
see also the Fleetwood Mac clause
& excuse me, Rush are Canadian
take that man away!

Please be aware
I have another list here of more than
100 bands mere mention of whose names
could result in instant prison time

Which also +++ pauses for lunch +++
discounts the Beach Boys, face it very
inconsistent, excuse me, did I hear someone say
what about the Monkees!

*Bangs gavel*

*Clears throat*

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury there
  remain two credible candidates
     whose brief but impactful careers
      appealed to different generations
        broke across political divides and

[[[transcript ends here]]]

No comments:

Post a Comment